A person employed as Assistant Librarian of a College is not to be considered as teacher, and cannot be permitted to continue in college up to 60 yrs

Section 2(34) of Maharashtra Universities Act 1994 (as amended by Act 55 of 2000) The amended definition of “Teacher”.


Although, the Assistant Librarian of a University has been covered by the definition of teacher, the Assistant Librarian of the College has been advisedly not been included in the definition. The amended definition of "teacher" does not cover the Assistant Librarian of a college.


Therefore a person employed as an Assistant Librarian of the college is not to be considered as a teacher, and cannot be permitted to continue in college up to 60 years of age.


Source: 2007 (3) Maharashtra Law Journal 811 (Shaila Arun Limaye Vs. State of Maharashtra)

Disengagement of workmen engaged from time to time for fixed periodsas the exigencies of work required, not a retrenchment

Disengagement of an a workman engaged from time to time for fixed periods as the exigencies of work reequired, upon the expiry of the period of contractual appointment, would not amount to retrenchment even if the employee had worked for 240 days in immediately preceding calendar year. Section 25 F of Industrial Disputes Act, not attracted in such case.


Source: (2007) 3 Mh. L. J. 882 (Prakash Sawant Vs. Punjab and Sind Bank)

Whether High Court can grant relief on merits in a Contempt Petition when there was mere a direction by the court to "consider"

The court had directed to consider employees’ representation. The representation was considered and rejected on merits. Employee instead of assailing rejection in a fresh Writ Petiton, filed contempt Petition.


High Court disposed of the Contempt Petition by directing that the employee be absorbed in a suitable post.


Such an order is wholly without jurisdiction and should not have been passed. High Court cnanot give relief on merits, especially if contempt petition is not maintainable.


Source: (2000) 10 SCC 285

How the validity of order by statutory authority should be judged?

It should be judged by the reasons so mentioned in the order. The reasons cannot be supplemented by fresh reasons in the shape of affidavit or otherwise.

Source: AIR 1978 SC 851 (Mohinder Singh Vs. The Cheif Election Commisisoner)

Grant of approval by Education Officer is not a condition precedent toa valid order of appointment

Under Maharashtra Employees of Private Schools (Conditions of Service) Regualtion Act, grant of approval by Education Officer is not a condition precedent to a valid order of appointment.


Want of approval to appointment will not invalidate an order of appointmnet.


Source: (2007) 1 Mh. L. J. 597 (Full Bench)